I'm making four puzzle games for my mum, because the ones on her phone are mostly ads
My mum plays four puzzle games on her phone: a water sort, a bubble shooter, a marble chain shooter and a match-3 with a house to decorate. All four are built around ads, lives and timers. I read about 11,000 of their store reviews, wrote down what people hate and what they love, and I'm making her four games of my own: Tidy Tubes, Bubble Meadow, Marble Brook and Lavender Lane. No ads, no lives, no timers, every level checked by a computer, one purchase. They are not in the stores yet.
My mum plays on her phone every day. Four games, always the same four. I looked at what she actually gets, and I didn't like it. A level, then a video. A lost level, then a wait or a payment. A countdown in the corner. A button that offers one more move for watching one more ad.
She likes the puzzles. Everything around the puzzles is there to wear her down. So I decided to make her the same four kinds of game without any of that, and to make them well enough that I'd play them too.
What 11,000 reviews say about these games
Before writing any code I collected the public reviews of the four games she plays: 6,897 from the App Store and 4,582 from Google Play. I sorted the complaints and the praise. The picture was the same for all four.
| People complain about | What I do instead |
|---|---|
| Ads | None. Not in the free part, not in the full game, not as a reward. |
| “I paid, ads stayed” | One purchase for the full game. Nothing else is ever sold. |
| Lives and coins | They don't exist. Lose a level and try again at once. |
| Rigged levels | A solver or a computer player checks every level before it ships. Nothing adapts against you. |
| Lost progress | Progress is saved on the phone and can be exported to a file. No account. |
| Tiny, same-looking pieces | A symbol on every colour, a Large mode, text up to 200%. |
The praise was just as consistent: people love these games for being calm, for keeping the head busy, for working without internet, and for controls they already know. One review with more than ten thousand likes asked why nobody sells a game like this for a dollar, with no ads and no purchases. That question is more or less the brief.
The rules I set for all four
- No ads, ever. No lives, coins, energy, timers or limited-time events.
- The first levels and the daily puzzle are free forever. The full game is one purchase, planned at $4.99, and it never renews.
- Every level is proven winnable by code before it ships, and the game never changes the odds while you play.
- You can't get stuck: hints, undo, and after five tries a level can be skipped.
- Readable by someone who isn't twenty: big buttons, symbols for colour-blind players, nothing drawn over the board.
- Offline, no account, your data stays on your phone.
- Quiet. No nagging notifications; a reminder exists only if you switch it on.
The four games
- Tidy Tubes, a water sort with 400 levels checked by a solver. Pick a photo of a flower or a sunset and its colours become the liquids of a new level. The photo stays on the phone.
- Bubble Meadow, a bubble shooter with 300 levels checked by a computer player. It has a steady-hand mode for fingers that shake, and a meadow that grows a flower for every pop.
- Marble Brook, a marble chain shooter with 200 levels on 20 brooks. Draw a brook with your finger and send it to someone as a short code. In quiet mode the stream waits for you.
- Lavender Lane, a match-3 with 200 levels and a cottage to decorate. The cottage is alive: the kettle steams, the light follows the clock, a cat moves in. Grandma sends postcards with recipes.
Each one also has an endless mode, so the game doesn't end when the levels do, and a daily puzzle that is the same for everyone.
What “fair” means here
In the reviews, “the game is rigged” comes right after ads. I can't argue someone out of that feeling, so I made it checkable. In Tidy Tubes a solver finds the shortest solution for every level, and that number is the par you see. In the other three a computer player plays each level many times before the level is allowed in. Lavender Lane keeps a level only if that player wins between 35% and 80% of 500 attempts: not a coin toss, not a gift.
The same code runs on the phone. In Tidy Tubes the hint button doesn't guess, it asks that solver for the next move.
Where they are now
All four are playable and none is in a store yet. The target is 60 frames a second on a cheap 32-bit Motorola, because that is closer to the phone these games get played on than my own. Tidy Tubes passes it; the other three still have to be measured there. Then they go to the stores one at a time, not as a pack.
My mum gets the first builds. If she puts one down after two days, I'll know which one to fix.
Want to try them before they're public? Sign up as a tester and say you want the games. Each game has its own page: Tidy Tubes, Bubble Meadow, Marble Brook, Lavender Lane.